Thursday, February 1, 2007
In the presence of the Divine.
Triggered by the combination of a conversation in my "Method and Theories in the Study of Religion" class and this Queen of Wands strip.
When I very little, at the Cathey's Creek, there were two chairs at the front of the auditorium -- one on either side of the pulpit. As a small child (six or sevenish), I was convinced that one chair was for Jesus and one chair was for God. (Holy Spirit? What's that? Church of Christ, darlings, they won't touch the Holy Spirit with a ten foot pole. I didn't figure out what the Holy Spirit until I was eleven or twelve, at least, possibly older.) No one ever sat in them and the chairs actually had upholstery. It made sense that Jesus and God were present and they got to sit in the better chairs.
Then there was a gospel meeting, or a youth rally, or something, and some speaker sat in the chair.
Was my little self upset? Yes.
After this event, even though I knew that the chairs were for speakers and not deities, I still liked to think of them as being chairs for God and Jesus. Maybe this sheds some light on my attractive to iconography. If there isn't an official physical manifestation of the spiritual presence, I'll apparently intuitively make a symbol out of some object.
Don't know why I felt like sharing that, but there you go.
When I very little, at the Cathey's Creek, there were two chairs at the front of the auditorium -- one on either side of the pulpit. As a small child (six or sevenish), I was convinced that one chair was for Jesus and one chair was for God. (Holy Spirit? What's that? Church of Christ, darlings, they won't touch the Holy Spirit with a ten foot pole. I didn't figure out what the Holy Spirit until I was eleven or twelve, at least, possibly older.) No one ever sat in them and the chairs actually had upholstery. It made sense that Jesus and God were present and they got to sit in the better chairs.
Then there was a gospel meeting, or a youth rally, or something, and some speaker sat in the chair.
Was my little self upset? Yes.
After this event, even though I knew that the chairs were for speakers and not deities, I still liked to think of them as being chairs for God and Jesus. Maybe this sheds some light on my attractive to iconography. If there isn't an official physical manifestation of the spiritual presence, I'll apparently intuitively make a symbol out of some object.
Don't know why I felt like sharing that, but there you go.
Sunday, January 28, 2007
I was watching the local news last night and finally heard about the scandal at Bellevue. (Well, the lastest scandal, I had heard about the money issues.) Leave it to me to know more about whats going on in Moscow (homophobic nutter of mayor, by the way) than what's going on in Memphis.
It's terrible what happened, and it would be terrible even if the man in question weren't a minister. "Moral failure" hardly begins to adequately describe a man molesting his son or any other child. The massive mismanagement of this situation by the leadership of Bellevue Baptist seems, to me, demonstrate some of the flaws of a megachurch model. Also, here is probably a good place to confess that I don't consistently attend any church.
I should start by noting that this is in no way an unbiased report. I am deeply bothered by the existence of Bellevue Baptist. (Not nessecarily the people in Bellevue Baptist, I'm sure that the majority of the individuals who compose the congregation are wonderful people.) They are a number of reasons, but mostly, I'm deeply skeptical of the megachurch model and consider health and wealth gospels to be bad theology. The lack of transparency regarding the use of church funds is also a bit disturbing, but hey, it ain't my money.
The investigative report released by the church repeatedly refers to the abuse (mind you, not alleged abuse, admitted to abuse) as "the seventeen-year-old issue." Somehow just doesn't seem adequate. Further, it's a bit saddening that Bellevue seems more concerned with the welfare of their corporate church than with the welfare of the victim. They are more indignant that Williams, referred to in the report as "Paul" continued on as a member of the ministerial staff than they are with the initial abuse.
I think that a lot of these problems can be traced back to the inherent flaws with the megachurch model. Obviously, the abuse itself isn't a result, but the manner in which this "seventeen-year-old issue" has been handled can be. To defend the senior pastor from accusations that he allowed Williams to continue in a role which included interviewing applicants for the lay ministry who indicated that they had been sexually abused in the past (See Wendi Thomas's column from the Commercial Appeal. He may indeed have treated such people inappropriately.) the committee claimed that "Dr. Gaines had only passing knowledge of what Mr. Williams’ job duties were." (emphasis mine)
Wait! How can it be construed as a good thing that the senior pastor of a church has "only passing knowledge" of the duties of a member of the ministry staff? If a senior pastor doesn't know the job descriptions of the ministry, how can he possibly minister effectively to the individual members of his church?
This is probably a matter of opinion, but it is my opinion that megachurches can not effectively create a sense of community and the family of God. I'm sure that, to a certain extent, participation in smaller groups can create a sense of belonging within a larger congregation, and all of this is a matter of personal preference, I suppose. But I have trouble finding a church that is so large the senior pastor doesn't even know the duties of the ministerial staff to be an attractive option in anyway. The connection between people within a church is very important to me, even to the extent of being able to overcome massive theological differences. At the church I used to attend, the minister I agreed on very few theological matters (inspiration of the Bible, role of women in the church, etc.) and yet, I would go to him with spiritual questions and listen to his advice. Why? Because I knew him. I knew he took matters of theology and spirituality very seriously, and more importantly, I knew that he took me seriously as an individual with a specific context, specific spiritual needs, and as a unique and full human being. I would be more inclined to attend that church when I am home if he were still there. I don't see how that could be replicated in a congregation of over 27,000 members. (Frankly, I think the 600 is pushing too many.) Currently, the only churches that begin to attract me are smaller congregations, where I feel I could develop a personal relationship with a number people, including the person who is supposed to "pastor" (shepherd) my soul.
Last semester I completed a class project that involved research at two Memphis churches. One was quite large (not Bellevue, btw) and one was a small congregation. Just from my observations, I don't think I would ever be content at the large congregation. Although I disagreed with a good bit of the theology I heard, that wasn't the only reason. (I also disagreed with parts of the dogma of the small church.) I felt comfortable enough at one of the two services I attended. (At the other, I was up in arms over a health and wealth sermon.) But other than the absolutely wonderful usher greeted me with a huge smile, I didn't welcomed. I doubt that anyone knew or could have known that I was a visitor. This isn't an the fault of anyone at that church. How can you know if someone is a visitor when there are over a 1,000 people at one of the six services? I'm also concerned by the fact that our group couldn't get in contact with one of the ministers at the church.
In contrast, when I attended the smaller congregation, I and one of my groupmates were approached by several members after the service who introduced themselves, chatted with us for a while, and then volunteered to help us in any way they could. The priest was easy to contact, and has already unintentionally provided me with a bit of spiritual guidance. (A sign-off or "forgive" at the end of an e-mail can mean a lot.) I already feel rather at home at that congregation, even though I have only attended three services and those sporadically.
But maybe this is just me.
It's terrible what happened, and it would be terrible even if the man in question weren't a minister. "Moral failure" hardly begins to adequately describe a man molesting his son or any other child. The massive mismanagement of this situation by the leadership of Bellevue Baptist seems, to me, demonstrate some of the flaws of a megachurch model. Also, here is probably a good place to confess that I don't consistently attend any church.
I should start by noting that this is in no way an unbiased report. I am deeply bothered by the existence of Bellevue Baptist. (Not nessecarily the people in Bellevue Baptist, I'm sure that the majority of the individuals who compose the congregation are wonderful people.) They are a number of reasons, but mostly, I'm deeply skeptical of the megachurch model and consider health and wealth gospels to be bad theology. The lack of transparency regarding the use of church funds is also a bit disturbing, but hey, it ain't my money.
The investigative report released by the church repeatedly refers to the abuse (mind you, not alleged abuse, admitted to abuse) as "the seventeen-year-old issue." Somehow just doesn't seem adequate. Further, it's a bit saddening that Bellevue seems more concerned with the welfare of their corporate church than with the welfare of the victim. They are more indignant that Williams, referred to in the report as "Paul" continued on as a member of the ministerial staff than they are with the initial abuse.
If he had considered the welfare of the church family, he would have resigned. The molestation of a child is bad enough, but to continue on in a ministerial capacity with responsibility for sensitive areas of our church life is without excuse.To explain the lag between the senior pastor of Bellevue knowing and taking action the investigative commitee claimed that
Although there is no excuse, there is an explanation which leads to the recommendation noted above. The Pastor stated that he had never dealt with an incident of this type before. Further, there were no policies and procedures in place that he had been trained to follow. In the past, the circle of information on any problems of a sensitive nature in the church was kept very tight to protect the families of the individuals and to protect the church from embarrassment.Bullshit! So good to know that Bellevue is more interested in protecting its corporate self from embarrassment than obeying state laws (Which don't I think conflict with any Biblical laws, God forgives and forgets, humans should forgive, not nessecarily forget.) than with protecting individual people from harm.
I think that a lot of these problems can be traced back to the inherent flaws with the megachurch model. Obviously, the abuse itself isn't a result, but the manner in which this "seventeen-year-old issue" has been handled can be. To defend the senior pastor from accusations that he allowed Williams to continue in a role which included interviewing applicants for the lay ministry who indicated that they had been sexually abused in the past (See Wendi Thomas's column from the Commercial Appeal. He may indeed have treated such people inappropriately.) the committee claimed that "Dr. Gaines had only passing knowledge of what Mr. Williams’ job duties were." (emphasis mine)
Wait! How can it be construed as a good thing that the senior pastor of a church has "only passing knowledge" of the duties of a member of the ministry staff? If a senior pastor doesn't know the job descriptions of the ministry, how can he possibly minister effectively to the individual members of his church?
This is probably a matter of opinion, but it is my opinion that megachurches can not effectively create a sense of community and the family of God. I'm sure that, to a certain extent, participation in smaller groups can create a sense of belonging within a larger congregation, and all of this is a matter of personal preference, I suppose. But I have trouble finding a church that is so large the senior pastor doesn't even know the duties of the ministerial staff to be an attractive option in anyway. The connection between people within a church is very important to me, even to the extent of being able to overcome massive theological differences. At the church I used to attend, the minister I agreed on very few theological matters (inspiration of the Bible, role of women in the church, etc.) and yet, I would go to him with spiritual questions and listen to his advice. Why? Because I knew him. I knew he took matters of theology and spirituality very seriously, and more importantly, I knew that he took me seriously as an individual with a specific context, specific spiritual needs, and as a unique and full human being. I would be more inclined to attend that church when I am home if he were still there. I don't see how that could be replicated in a congregation of over 27,000 members. (Frankly, I think the 600 is pushing too many.) Currently, the only churches that begin to attract me are smaller congregations, where I feel I could develop a personal relationship with a number people, including the person who is supposed to "pastor" (shepherd) my soul.
Last semester I completed a class project that involved research at two Memphis churches. One was quite large (not Bellevue, btw) and one was a small congregation. Just from my observations, I don't think I would ever be content at the large congregation. Although I disagreed with a good bit of the theology I heard, that wasn't the only reason. (I also disagreed with parts of the dogma of the small church.) I felt comfortable enough at one of the two services I attended. (At the other, I was up in arms over a health and wealth sermon.) But other than the absolutely wonderful usher greeted me with a huge smile, I didn't welcomed. I doubt that anyone knew or could have known that I was a visitor. This isn't an the fault of anyone at that church. How can you know if someone is a visitor when there are over a 1,000 people at one of the six services? I'm also concerned by the fact that our group couldn't get in contact with one of the ministers at the church.
In contrast, when I attended the smaller congregation, I and one of my groupmates were approached by several members after the service who introduced themselves, chatted with us for a while, and then volunteered to help us in any way they could. The priest was easy to contact, and has already unintentionally provided me with a bit of spiritual guidance. (A sign-off or "forgive" at the end of an e-mail can mean a lot.) I already feel rather at home at that congregation, even though I have only attended three services and those sporadically.
But maybe this is just me.
Saturday, January 27, 2007
Jessie's Pet Skunk: A Sordid Tale of Jealousy
My great-aunt used to tell me a story, when I was little, about her sister's pet skunk.
Jessie had adopted a baby skunk they had found in the woods. She feed it. She washed it daily, and it was generally a good little pet. During the summers, their father used to set up a cot on the porch to sleep on. He decided that he would let the skunk sleep with him.
Now my great grandfather had a little hound dog, who became jealous of the skunk. He'd sit on the front doorstep and stare at the skunk curled up next to my great grandfather.
One day, everyone left to go into town, and the skunk and little dog were left at home. When they got back, the skunk was gone and the little dog was sitting on the doorstep. Jessie went around the house looking for her pet skunk and finally came back to the front porch.
Jessie stared at the little dog. The little dog wouldn't look at Jessie.
Jessie had adopted a baby skunk they had found in the woods. She feed it. She washed it daily, and it was generally a good little pet. During the summers, their father used to set up a cot on the porch to sleep on. He decided that he would let the skunk sleep with him.
Now my great grandfather had a little hound dog, who became jealous of the skunk. He'd sit on the front doorstep and stare at the skunk curled up next to my great grandfather.
One day, everyone left to go into town, and the skunk and little dog were left at home. When they got back, the skunk was gone and the little dog was sitting on the doorstep. Jessie went around the house looking for her pet skunk and finally came back to the front porch.
Jessie stared at the little dog. The little dog wouldn't look at Jessie.
Friday, January 26, 2007
I hate to say it . . .
But, Putin might have a point.
Not that Russia is perfectly innocent, but there is something a little wrong about the US attitude of, "we can have weapons, and we can create weapons, but you try to make your own weapons, we will consider you an aggressor."
Quote from The Associated Press, via The Moscow TimesAsked about the Chinese test at a news conference in New Delhi after a meeting with Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, Putin avoided directly criticizing China, saying only that Russia was against putting any weapons in space.
Instead, Putin chose to issue a warning to the United States on the dangers of the militarization of space.
"At the same time, I would like to note that China was not the first country to conduct such a test," Putin said.
Not that Russia is perfectly innocent, but there is something a little wrong about the US attitude of, "we can have weapons, and we can create weapons, but you try to make your own weapons, we will consider you an aggressor."
Plurals formed with "-i" are just more fun.
Over the summer, my muse and I had moment that involved me stepping out of the shower one morning and promptly curling up on the bathmat waiting for a menstrual cramp to go away. I believe I muttered something to the effect of "It my uterus had any value I would sell it on the black market." Which, as anyone who knows me knows, wouldn't happen. As such a process would likely involve needles.
But the muse whispered in my ear: There's a story in that statement.
Having made in out of the bathroom floor to my computer, this obedient little slave of the muse hit the internet and discovered that uteri have no black market value. Rather upset at first, I soon began to consider other things characters could sell, like eggs. (This, by the way, resulted in a rather strange story.)
But now, perhaps, I can indeed pursue the black-market uterus story! It could be a fun sci-fiesque thing.
Although, my mind remains boggled, but to each her own.
But the muse whispered in my ear: There's a story in that statement.
Having made in out of the bathroom floor to my computer, this obedient little slave of the muse hit the internet and discovered that uteri have no black market value. Rather upset at first, I soon began to consider other things characters could sell, like eggs. (This, by the way, resulted in a rather strange story.)
But now, perhaps, I can indeed pursue the black-market uterus story! It could be a fun sci-fiesque thing.
Although, my mind remains boggled, but to each her own.
Of music and martyrs...
My brain apparently links "Imitation of Life," by REM, with martyrdom, and particularly martyrdom as a physical imitation of Christ. Interesting, brain, interesting.
Seneca's theme song is now Soundgarden's "Blow off the Outside World." Because "nothing seems to kill him, no matter how hard he tries."
And, Mieke Bal tells me in Narratology that characters have no psychological reality. To Mieke Bal I say: Tell that to the voices in my head.
Seneca's theme song is now Soundgarden's "Blow off the Outside World." Because "nothing seems to kill him, no matter how hard he tries."
And, Mieke Bal tells me in Narratology that characters have no psychological reality. To Mieke Bal I say: Tell that to the voices in my head.
Wednesday, January 24, 2007
Listening to Russian sing about being smashed apart....or something like that.
I'm taking a class titled "The Redeemed Body" this semester. Title vague enough for you? The class is about martyrdom and asceticism. As a backdrop, we read some Seneca on the noble death, suicide, taking control of the end of one's life, rather than allowing it to be controlled by outside forces.
During class discussion the other day, I realized the opinion I hold -- that there can be situations in which it is rational to commit suicide -- is considered weird. The people -- in my class, at least -- automatically consider any suicide to be the result of depression or trauma. Suicide could not, regardless of context, be a rational decision. To me, that's flawed enough logic to apply to today's world and even worse logic to try to apply to Roman philosophers.
Later, as I continued to turn the discussion over in my head, I realized that our culture (United States of America, contemporary) doesn't really even consider the acceptance of death to be a rational mindset. So much energy is spent trying to stop death, to live just a little while longer, even when the chance of a treatment working is slim to nothing. If a person has a near-terminal illness and decides not to pursure treatment, they are considered to be unbalanced and perhaps even in violation of the law, if they happen to be younger than eighteen. A simple acceptance that death is the human fate is considered morbid, not realistic. Part of this is based on my own experience of how people respond when they find out that I have no interest in heroic efforts being made to save my life should I be gravely injured or fall ill. (The answer is not well, and sometimes they then ask me if I'm suicidal. Usually, they just insist that as a young person, I have no right to an opinion on such things.) Part of this is based on reading articles about attempts by the government to force teenagers to continue with chemotherapy, when they feel that the slim chance the treatment will cure them is not worth the pain cause by the treatment. Part of this is probably rage at a system that thinks allowing a person to starve over a week or so once her body has forgotten how to eat and drink is somehow more dignified or humane than an overdose of morphine.
I'm not sure what to make of it. Or me.
During class discussion the other day, I realized the opinion I hold -- that there can be situations in which it is rational to commit suicide -- is considered weird. The people -- in my class, at least -- automatically consider any suicide to be the result of depression or trauma. Suicide could not, regardless of context, be a rational decision. To me, that's flawed enough logic to apply to today's world and even worse logic to try to apply to Roman philosophers.
Later, as I continued to turn the discussion over in my head, I realized that our culture (United States of America, contemporary) doesn't really even consider the acceptance of death to be a rational mindset. So much energy is spent trying to stop death, to live just a little while longer, even when the chance of a treatment working is slim to nothing. If a person has a near-terminal illness and decides not to pursure treatment, they are considered to be unbalanced and perhaps even in violation of the law, if they happen to be younger than eighteen. A simple acceptance that death is the human fate is considered morbid, not realistic. Part of this is based on my own experience of how people respond when they find out that I have no interest in heroic efforts being made to save my life should I be gravely injured or fall ill. (The answer is not well, and sometimes they then ask me if I'm suicidal. Usually, they just insist that as a young person, I have no right to an opinion on such things.) Part of this is based on reading articles about attempts by the government to force teenagers to continue with chemotherapy, when they feel that the slim chance the treatment will cure them is not worth the pain cause by the treatment. Part of this is probably rage at a system that thinks allowing a person to starve over a week or so once her body has forgotten how to eat and drink is somehow more dignified or humane than an overdose of morphine.
I'm not sure what to make of it. Or me.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)